| I think it's a 5, or 6 at most. People can have different opinions, you know. |
  |
| I think the reviewers were haters it doesnt deserve 1, more on 4 or 5. Its enjoyable anime that doesnt taking seriously. |
 |
| This anime does not deserve an 8 lmao.It will be 5-6 at the most.This anime also doesn't make any sense.Let me give you an example of an dialogue of Anos Voldigoad-'Do you think by stabbing me would be enough to make m die'?Wtf is that??? |
 Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
| Because it's cool and edgy to hate on isekai shows with op protags for no reason Yeah, it's a good show imo |
 |
| The rating isn't even that bad lmao what you mean, yea the top review is a 1 but that's not surprising considering reviews only become popular because of controversy |
 |
Scordolo said: Let me give you an example of an dialogue of Anos Voldigoad-'Do you think by stabbing me would be enough to make m die'?Wtf is that??? How is that confusing ? Its very literal sentence. |
 |
| It definitely doesn't deserve a 1, but additionally it is also one of the least impressive anime I've ever seen. The score should be around 4 to 6 at most. |
ExtremeBoxing said: Scordolo said: This anime does not deserve an 8 lmao.It will be 5-6 at the most.This anime also doesn't make any sense.Let me give you an example of an dialogue of Anos Voldigoad-'Do you think by stabbing me would be enough to make m die'?Wtf is that??? lmao I absolutely loved it when he said that and anime doesn’t need to make sense imo aslong as it’s enjoyable and for me it is very enjoyable. For YOU. Good for you, mate. No one else really cares, or really agrees, and that's that. Like, nice that you gave it an 8? |
Please sign up for MangAlert! It's a little project I made that I'd really like to see the light of day and some users. MangAlert! (please sign up!) GitHub Repo (please star!) |
| OP protags are not a bad idea unless the setting itself is just bad. On the positive spectrum, we have Overlord, Cautious Hero, OPM, Slime, etc. On the negative spectrum, we have Smartphone which is just stupidly frustrating to watch🤣 |
 |
| It's very enjoyable because it has competent director. |
 |
| Idk I have this on my plan to watch, you guys are starting to scare me. is it really that bad??? |
 |
| We all know why but what matter is that they are failing. The show is still solidly above 7.5 and it will stay like that. zRise said: People always seem to rate Anime of this type badly, usually because they are too elitist to understand the nuiance, "Power Fantasy" anime such as this, Kenji no Mago, Reincarnated as a slime and to be honest every single Isekai anime apart from Re: Zero all suffer from this problem, they want superserious anime with really in depth plots and if its a proffessional review often some kind of Political message mixed in. I love darker more serious anime, i recently just binged the Whole of "Pyscho Pass" including the movies but i am also a huge fan of SAO its good to break things up and change to something lighter or easier to watch, most anime rate 6/7 are perfectly watchable anime, i even found "Isekai Cheat Magician" to be quite enjoyable another i found entertaining was "Knights and Magic" People who write reviews takes themselves too seriously, just sit back and relax, there is more than 1 type of story. This^ This 1000 times. Rizki_Diablo said: popular reason to give this series with 1-5 is 1. mistakenly this series as isekai just because there is reincarnation element in it Imagine giving a show a maximum of 5/10 solely because it's isekai, lol. It's almost like those ones "a ecchi show can't be good because it's ecchi" lmao. Fortunately not everyone is like that... Amatniki said: Idk I have this on my plan to watch, you guys are starting to scare me. is it really that bad??? It's not. edit: watched it in one go. It's very good, indeed. |
FullyChargedSep 27, 2020 9:04 AM
| bruh |
Amatniki said: Idk I have this on my plan to watch, you guys are starting to scare me. is it really that bad??? Au contraire. It's a mindless, fun, chill show to watch. A couple laughs, OP protagonist and some quality time to be had. It's almost a parody unto itself, and if you just let it be what it is without attaching your own half-truths and expectations to it, you'll have a blast. Give it a whirl; it's not so much that it's worth it, but for shits and giggles. That's what this show does, and it does it really well. |
     |
| “Do you think rating my show a “1” would be enough to make me die?” - Anos Voldigoad |
| “SAITO! YOU NEED TO EXPLODE! FOR THE WORLD’S SAKE!” |
| Haters will be Haters!! If you ask them what they don't like about this anime....they'll say Anos is tooooooo OP to be True!! Lol |
 |
| I don't mind 1/10 rating its just everyone has their own opinion preference and lots of other things that affect their score when rating an anime, and it's mostly case-by-case no matter how you look at it I'm more confused on people that rate an anime without finishing it like usually after 1 or 3 episode, I'm not saying you have to watch the entire thing to form an opinion but if you stop watching midway isn't it make more sense to just not give a score and put it on "Dropped" since you don't even sit through the entire thing?. for example, just look at ongoing anime "review", but then again reading a review on myani is a bad way to decide to watch an anime or not, so I'm kinda exaggerating a bit here so take it with a grain of salt |
| There's honestly not much of a reason other than the minority are just more vocal with their dislike of the show, hence why 10% of users rated the show 5 or lower while the 90% rest of mal users rated it higher. Same goes with the current top reviews trashing on the show, more people like the show and that's pretty much it |
| I think people giving it 1 is probably because of pure hate, and not an objective review. I personally give this a 5/6 because even though the story was not that new or groundbreaking, it is an anime that is fun to watch, and this by the fact I finished watching the anime. |
 |
| This type of show is my jam but I see that's not for everyone, I think it's a low 7, high 6 and can understand why people would rate it even lower, although I agree that scoring one is kinda troll but then again scoring this a 10 also is. Also the final episodes was like average at most and way too cringe with the singing and shit. I don't usually say something is rushed but this show should have like 26 episodes or something to develop more of the characters and the history of the world etc.... |
ExtremeBoxing said: Dunno if that will help you but here we go. Why does everyone in the reviews give it a 1-5? I think it’s a 8 at the least Initially I rated it 6. After final EP, that was pretty dull, I checked my MAL list to compare it with "similar" shows and the score I gave them. So I typed 'maou' in search engine: - Hataraku Maou-sama! at 7 - Isekai Maou to Shoukan Shoujo no Dorei Majutsu at 6 I didn't enjoy Maou Gakuin no Futekigousha as much as these two (and many other shows I gave 6), so I settled at 5 as final score. If I were to rate it any higher I'd have to review a lot of my other anime ratings. I do that from time to time but in this case I don't see a point. Tbh as I scroll through my list this show fits perfectly into my other 5's. As for why 1s? I think most of these people dropped this anime after 1-2 eps and when it ended changed it's status to completed. You know, to expand their MAL list that boost their egos - "oh look at me, I've watched 100000 anime so I'm real kawaii expert otaku" ¯_(ツ)_/¯ SRASinister said: Short answer: they probably don't. You can't verify if I (or anyone else) watched even 1 minute of any anime and I can still put it on MAL as completed and rate it as I like. I can give 10 to a total crap or 1 to a masterpiece. That is the "problem" with rating/review sites; be it anime, movies, music, books or anything else. That's why you usually get to see an average score, where 10s and 1s aren't really important since they nullify each other.To me it's mind boggling how someone can watch every episode and give an anime a 1 rating. E: Check list of the guy who posted below me - that's what I'm talking about. He probably never watched half of the shows on his list from start to finish. Especially the ones he gave lowest score but his edginess (in his eyes) is over 9000. I'd never finish a show that is even remotely close to 1 but he had no problems with that even if anime has +20 episodes ;) |
Old-geezerSep 26, 2020 4:20 PM
| I personally don’t think it’s a 1/10 after much consideration. Yea, it’s your typical power fantasy with an OPed MC in an academy setting and doesn’t have the best production value, either. But I personally think there was some value in terms of amusement from Anos purposely flexing. At least it has some sense of self-awareness and dumb fun context. I’m not saying it’s good at all, it’s still pretty bad, but in the end I think it’s around 3/10. |
 |
| Because people are unable to read the tone of the show somehow ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ |
Scordolo said: This anime does not deserve an 8 lmao.It will be 5-6 at the most.This anime also doesn't make any sense.Let me give you an example of an dialogue of Anos Voldigoad-'Do you think by stabbing me would be enough to make m die'?Wtf is that???  For real tho this was probably one of the best scenes in the show. |
Sark_MorganSep 26, 2020 6:52 PM
| I don't understand how someone makes it through an entire show where the entire point is it whole heartedly embraces totally overpowered anime logic and tropes in a satirical way and then says "show bad because doesn't make any sense for x y z reason." You guys do realize the main character beats the stuffing out of a guy in the first episode with his heart beat. The show isn't meant to make sense. The show is hilariously broken. The final episode there are MANY moments where you can tell that they basically said "what would be the most ridiculous thing that another show might actually do in this genre that absolutely wouldn't make any sense or fit the flow at all?" "Ah yes, let's throw in a song about friendship that empowers the demon king out of nowhere, and everyone will know the correct lyrics to the improvised song." It doesn't get much more blatant than this without straight putting a disclaimer on the screen that points out that the show is satirical. |
Z1Pex said: Simple, they are most likely just trolling. Who in the right mind would actually watch a show with 13+ episodes (around 3-5 hours depending how much you skip) just to put it as a 1. Literally nobody, they all just put it as complete and then just put whatever score they want and give a review. I couls say the same at trolls who rate it 10, there's more of them after all, you know. |
 |
| No way this anime is better than average, so 1-5 is a completely justified score to give, depends on how much they think it sucked. I would have given it a 6 but after that last ep, I needed to reconsider it. |
CesarMagnan said: it definitely is, a lot of criticisms on this show is overblown to say the leastFor me it was the most enjoyable new anime in this season, without counting the second or third season of other anime. |
| Whatever they do, it's not working (at least at the time this comment was made) because the anime rating is still 7.5 and I'm pretty sure it'll stay like that. not like rating in MAL really matters anyway lol I still think the biggest factors are: 1. It's another overpowered MC, take Godsuya for example, even though the reason why he's OP is explained very well people still don't like him. 2. They're mistakenly thinking it was isekai because of the reincarnation element. EGOIST said: CesarMagnan said: it definitely is, a lot of criticisms on this show is overblown to say the leastFor me it was the most enjoyable new anime in this season, without counting the second or third season of other anime. Yeah, the only critics I have for this show is just that they skipped a lot of slice of life moments and some important dialogues. |
 |
| People like showing off their big dick energy by giving shows low scores. It has always been this way and it will never change. Just be glad you're not an elitist and move on. This show for example won't be for everyone, I get it. But if you put any thought into your scores you should realize there is no way this can be a 1 or 2/10. That's why you can't take any ratings seriously, it's better to ask a friend who got similar taste for a recommendation than MAL. Amatniki said: Idk I have this on my plan to watch, you guys are starting to scare me. is it really that bad??? It's really not. But it's not anything special, either. It's just a typical harem more or less. But the MC is above average, he's a chad and actually punishes villains, which was surprisingly enjoyable. |
MeriuSep 27, 2020 5:56 AM
 |